The financial valuation of a company is a crucial subject for company managers, investors and shareholders. It is important to note that the financial valuation of a company must be done in a transparent manner and in compliance with legal and regulatory rules and obligations. Company managers have a responsibility to ensure that the information they communicate is accurate and does not mislead investors.
There are many court rulings on this subject, and we'll be exploring them in this article, with the aim of illustrating the legal issues surrounding a company valuation.
Court decision and valuation
Some of the major decisions that have shaped the practice of corporate valuation:
- In the 2004 Paris Court of Appeal decision in the Vivendi Universal case, Vivendi Universal executives were found guilty of failing to report financial losses and failing to communicate transparently about the company's financial position
- In the 2007 Paris Court of Appeal ruling in the EADS case, EADS executives were found guilty of failing to communicate transparently about the financial risks of developing a new aircraft.
- In the 2011 ruling by the French Supreme Court in the Pernod Ricard case, Pernod Ricard was convicted of overstating the company's profits in its consolidated financial statements when it increased its capital in 2001.
- In the 2013 ruling by the Court of Cassation in the Vivendi case, Vivendi executives were found guilty of failing to report financial losses and failing to communicate transparently about the company's financial condition.
- The ruling by the Court of Cassation in 2014 in the Société Générale case, Société Générale was convicted of concealing information about the extent of losses related to the Jerome Kerviel case.
- The Paris Court of Appeals ruling in 2016 in the Bolloré case, Bolloré was convicted of concealing information about the company's financial results during a capital increase.
- The 2017 Court of Cassation ruling in the Casino Guichard case, Casino Guichard was convicted of concealing information about the company's financial results.
- The 2018 ruling by the Court of Cassation in the Alstom case, Alstom executives were found guilty of failing to report financial losses and failing to communicate transparently about the company's financial situation
- The Paris Court of Appeal's 2020 ruling in the Carrefour case, Carrefour was convicted of concealing information about the company's financial results.
- In the Vallourec case, the French Supreme Court ruled in 2020 that Vallourec had been convicted of concealing information about the company's financial results during a capital increase.
In all of these cases, the courts have indicated that corporate executives have a responsibility to ensure that the information they disclose is accurate and does not mislead investors.
The various jurisdictions have emphasized the importance of transparency in financial communication and are gradually laying down the rules for the valuation of a company during a capital increase or a disposal.
You wish to have more information from a XVAL consultant on the valuation of your company:
Valuation of companies: SMEs and small companies
For SMEs or unlisted companies, it is more difficult to find specific court decisions due to the lower visibility of these companies in the media and legal publications. However, it is important to note that the rules and obligations regarding financial valuation also apply to SMEs and non-listed companies.
2 examples in small companies:
- The decision rendered by the Court of Appeal of Toulouse in 2010 in the case of "a construction company" where the company was convicted of concealing financial losses when selling the company to a third party
- The decision rendered by the Court of Appeal of Versailles in 2011 in the case of "a company selling agricultural equipment" where the company was condemned for having concealed financial losses during a capital increase.
In both cases, the court emphasized that corporate executives have a responsibility to ensure that the information they disclose is accurate and does not mislead investors.
These examples show that the rules and obligations regarding financial valuation also apply to SMEs and unlisted companies, and that it is important for the managers of these companies to comply with these rules and to communicate transparently about the financial situation of their company
You wish to have more information from a XVAL consultant and realize the valuation of a company:
